Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /var/www/vhosts/philvideos.org/httpdocs/admin31Cx6Z77/classi/suggestedVideos.php on line 43

Prof. Achille Varzi‘s talk at the "Topological Philosophy Conference" 2016

Achille Varzi: "The Boundaries of Things: Where Topology Meets Metaphysics" Abstract Philosophical reflections on the topological notion of boundary tend to focus on the opposition between boundaries as basic, lower-dimensional entities and boundaries as derived, higher-order abstractions. This opposition reflects two fundamentally different ways of understanding the structure of space and time and has important ontological consequences when it comes to the structure and nature of those entities that may be said to be located in space and time, such as objects and events. There is, in addition, a second important distinction that may be drawn, and whose ontological ramifications extend even further—the distinction between natural (or bona fide) and artificial (or fiat) boundaries. The former are just the natural boundaries of old, as grounded in some factual discontinuity or qualitative heterogeneity betwixt an entity and its surroundings; the latter are exemplified especially by boundaries induced through human cognition and social practices and lie skew to any objective differentiations in the underlying wordly material (as with the contours in a Seurat painting, or the borders of Wyoming). The distinction bites deeply, for it can be drawn across the board: not merely in the domain of boundaries but also in relation to those entities that may be said to have boundaries. If a certain object or event enjoys a natural boundary, its identity and survival conditions do not depend on us; it is a bona fide, mind-independent entity of its own. By contrast, if its boundary is of the artificial sort, then the entity itself is to some degree a fiat entity, a product of our worldmaking. Now, we may disagree on which entities are of which sort, and any such disagreement will reflect a corresponding disagreement in matters of metaphysical realism. Indeed, it can be argued that the question of realism is, in an important sense, the question of what are the bona fide boundaries, the boundaries that “carve at the joints”. Here I am especially interested in limit case: What if there aren’t any? What if all boundaries—hence all entities—were on closer look and to some extent the product of some cognitive or social fiat? The "Topological Philosophy" conference was held on February 8 – 9, 2016 at the International Center for Formal Ontology (ICFO), Faculty of Administration and Social Sciences, Warsaw University of Technology, Poland. http://www.icfo.ans.pw.edu.pl/en/?page_id=15
#Comments

YOU NEED TO LOGIN IN ORDER TO COMMENT

TEXTUAL RESOURCES

other videos



video

PHILOSOPHY - Nietzsche

video

Ship of Theseus Thought Experiment

video

22.- I presocratici - Parmenide e lEssere Oltre Parmenide E Severino

video

Necessidade Natural e Metafiísica - prof. dr. João Branquinho (ULisboa - Portugal)

video

Lucio Cortella e G. W. F. Hegel - La fenomenologia dello Spirito [Parte II]

video

The myth of Sisyphus - Alex Gendler