Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /var/www/vhosts/philvideos.org/httpdocs/admin31Cx6Z77/classi/suggestedVideos.php on line 43

Is withholding blame dehumanising? | The Royal Institute of Philosophy | University of Birmingham

The Royal Institute of Philosophy Lecture given by Dr Nadine Elzein is Associate Professor in Philosophy at the University of Warwick. Abstract: Philosophers working on moral responsibility and punishment often defend a view which seems puzzling to those outside of philosophy: The view that we would not be treating someone as a person if we did not blame them for their wrongdoings and view them as deserving punishment for their crimes. Given that systems of punishment themselves often look quite dehumanising (UK prisons are rife with mental health problems and suicide), why would we think that withholding punishment might be worse? One worry is that a society that didn’t punish wrongdoers would instead have to treat them like animals or machines to be retrained or reprogrammed; We could manipulate them into better behaviour or “treat” their behaviour as if it were an illness, but we would fail to treat them as rational adults who make their own choices. I want to challenge this picture and to say something about how we might keep personhood but reject punishment.
#Comments

YOU NEED TO LOGIN IN ORDER TO COMMENT

TEXTUAL RESOURCES

other videos



video

2 DAVID HUME principi della morale

video

Libero arbitrio e imputabilità, M. De Caro

video

Do you think differently? Ethics and the Environment

video

"Qu'est-ce que la vie de l'esprit ?" questions à Pascal Engel

video

The myth of Sisyphus - Alex Gendler